Included In
Martindale-Hubbell Peer Rated 2021
Super Lawyers - David H. Ben Asher Super Lawyers - Jonathan I. Nirenberg
Super Lawyers - Omar A. Lopez
NELA

Employee Performance Evaluations

Information About Performance Evaluation From New Jersey Employment Lawyers

Employee Performance EvaluationsWhile not legally required, most employers in New York and New Jersey have a process to evaluate employee job performance. These processes range from informal evaluations to very formal review systems.

Performance reviews can vary greatly from company to company, and even from supervisor to supervisor. However, typically employers evaluate employees in various performance categories, using either a numerical system or categories such as “meets expectations,” “exceeds expectation” and “needs improvement.” Performance reviews also frequently include a narrative description of the employee’s strengths, weaknesses, and opportunities for improvement.

While reviews most often are prepared by an immediate supervisor, some companies have employees prepare self-evaluations for their supervisors to review and revise. Other businesses use additional forms of evaluation such as “360-degree reviews” in which supervisors, peers, and other employees provide feedback about the employee’s job performance.

What Should I Do if My Performance Evaluation is Unfair or Inaccurate?

Performance evaluations almost always include subjective opinions. As a result, it is common for employees to disagree with their evaluations. It also is not unusual for a supervisor to unfairly or inaccurately assess an employee’s job performance.

There is no one right or wrong way to respond to an inaccurate performance evaluation. Depending on the situation, it might make sense to speak directly to your supervisor, talk to someone in the Human Resources Department, or submit a written response. Of course, when doing so it is important not to be insubordinate or disrespectful to your superiors, or to do anything else that could jeopardize your future with your employer.

If you are asked to sign your performance review, you should read it carefully first. Generally, if you believe your performance review is inaccurate, you should not sign something that says you agree with it. However, there usually is no harm in signing something that merely confirms you received and read your review, as many employers require.

Depending on the situation, you might want to submit a response or rebuttal to your performance evaluation addressing the specific items you disagree with and explaining any special circumstances that might apply. In fact, many forms include a place for employees to include comments or responses. As noted above, you should be careful not to say anything that is insubordinate or likely to get you in trouble.

While you do not necessarily have a legal claim just because your company unfairly evaluated your job performance, an unfair or inaccurate assessment often can be a symptom of unlawful discrimination, retaliation, or another legal claim. As a result, it may be a good idea to talk to an employment attorney in New Jersey to evaluate whether your legal rights have been violated.

Performance Improvement Plans

In theory, a Performance Improvement Plan (or “PIP”) is intended to help a struggling employee improve his or her job performance. However, PIPs frequently are used to help justify demoting or firing employees. In those instances the company may set unreasonable goals or deadlines, provide little or no support to help you improve your work, or otherwise set you up for failure.

If you are placed on a Performance Improvement Plan you should take it very seriously since it is a warning sign that your job may be in jeopardy. In fact, you may want to speak to an employment lawyer to figure out the best way to protect your job.

Contacting a New Jersey Employment Lawyer

We welcome you to contact us if you would like to speak to one of our employment lawyers about your performance review, Performance Improvement Plan, or another issue related to your job.

Please feel free to contact us online, or call us at (973) 744-4000.

Client Reviews
★★★★★
"I worked with Jonathan Nirenberg, ESQ on a sensitive emotional employment matter. Mr. Nirenberg was quick to respond, offered excellent advice, and always followed up with phone calls or emails when needed. My situation was settled out of court within a short period of time with the best possible results for not just me but also for the employer. Highly recommend and would seek his help again if needed..." Linda Busch, PhD
★★★★★
"We've had the pleasure of working with Jonathan on multiple individual and class employment cases. Jonathan is a skilled, dedicated and caring attorney that works diligently to bring justice for his clients. We would recommend Jonathan as a legal resource for any employment cases." Stephan Zouras, LLP
★★★★★
"I felt alone and without a voice, until I hired Jonathan I. Nirenberg of Rabner Baumgart Ben-Asher & Nirenberg, P.C. Mr. Nirenberg represented me in an employment matter. Without his help, I know that I would not have had the extremely successful outcome I had. Jonathan was not only professional, but very empathetic to what happened to me. Jonathan gave me support, and options in relation to a challenging employer/employment situation which was an extremely difficult time in my life..." Shelly Smith